After
the gravity-defying climb to 19000 and above, the Sensex has come under pressure.
What are the possible scenarios that may play out in the near future and what
can investors do now? By Vivek Sharma
US Fed might have actually meant what it said:
When the US Fed dropped its target Fed rate by 50 percentage points, it said risks
to sustained economic expansion have increased after the credit market troubles.
Of course, stock markets didn''t believe the environment is that troublesome and
treated the rate cut as a welcome gift. What if the Fed was on the ball
and not over-reacting? In other words, what if the threat of a US economic
recession is quite real and warranted a sharp cut last time? Of course, the Fed
will cut rates again and markets will continue to party. But, for how
long? Until realisation dawns that rate cuts alone may not avoid a recession.
Corporate earnings will take a hit and valuations will suddenly look very expensive.
Those who argue that US stocks are now cheaper than they were at the height of
the last rally will find that they are inexpensive for a reason. The earnings
outlook is not all that rosy! The Fed might have over-reacted: If
indeed the Fed was crying wolf and economic conditions are not that bad, then
the markets are in for even more trouble. That could mean the Fed will not cut
rates as much as the markets expect now. It could also mean higher inflation risks,
as commodity and oil prices are at record highs. Credit markets may
see more jitters: In recent weeks, markets have behaved as if the credit market
woes were a mere nightmare from which we have all woken up to a bright, pleasant
day. Apart from the rescue packages doled out by central banks, major lenders
themselves have now formed a ''super fund'' to soak up distress sales of credit
derivatives and prevent further trouble. And, suddenly, all is well in this world!
But, pause for a moment and imagine the irony of the situation. Here are
a group of people, who messed up big time on their investment bets, who are now
borrowing money to buy the potentially dud investments from themselves if others
refuse to do so. In other words, they are raising money to buy these complex and
illiquid credit derivatives at prices fixed by them and then say they are worth
that much. There is something seriously wrong in this arrangement, especially
when many seem to have bought into the plan. Emerging markets may not
be the safe havens they are made out to be: The way emerging markets surged
in recent weeks, it would seem that global investors expect them to be islands
of safety even when ''emerged markets'' slip. But, emerging markets have their own
set of problems - which is part of their ''emerging'' identity. This was demonstrated
clearly in India last week, when SEBI spooked foreign investors with a googly
over the acceptability of PNotes, usually issued by hedge funds. And the trouble
with such googlies is that they encourage other players to come up with their
own versions. Like the demands for a complete ban on P-Notes from the Left and
the BJP. Similarly in China, much of the recent surge has come after a
government proposal to allow domestic investors to bet on overseas markets. The
outflow from Chinese investors to other regional markets, especially Hong Kong,
could be as high as $80 billion over the next year according to some estimates.
But, it is still only a proposal. Many a slip could happen between the cup and
the lip! Corporate earnings may disappoint: Many of the early results
from US companies have disappointed, with as many as a quarter of the earnings
announced so far coming below market expectations. The worst hit are obviously
the banks, as most of them had to take multi-billion dollar hits from credit market
losses. If the US housing downturn persists, they may see much more pain in coming
quarters. And, if that happens, it will be only a matter of time before other
sectors start disappointing. In India, technology earnings can be expected
to remain subdued in the foreseeable future. It was anyway unrealistic to expect
these companies to maintain hefty margins forever and now there is this sword
over their heads in the form of a climbing rupee. Many investors have betted heavily
on infrastructure plays, valuing them even more exorbitantly than tech stocks.
But, as the latest results from cement companies prove, high demand and record
product prices may not directly translate to the kind of bottom line growth investors
expect. Oil may soar above $100 per barrel: Global economic growth
has been surprisingly resilient to high oil prices over the last couple of years.
It could be that economic expansion is now less energy-dependent than in the past.
China and India, which along with Russia now account for nearly half of global
growth according to IMF, have lessened the impact of high energy prices on their
economies through higher subsidies. Besides, weaker dollar means high oil prices
have not pinched non-US consumers that hard. But there must be some price
point beyond which it will start hurting. As global economic growth looks increasingly
more vulnerable to a slowdown, that point may not be that far off. Oil
may correct: Logically, if oil corrects markets should be happy. Ironically,
that may be an even worse situation as stocks, especially in emerging markets,
could come under pressure. Energy stocks have led the recent surge on expectations
of record bottom lines on rising product prices and refining margins. Will
the markets still pay high premiums for Reliance Industries and Reliance Petroleum
for their potential future upsides, if oil slips to $60-65 per barrel? Will Petro
China, which is now the second most valuable company in the world, continue to
attract investor interest when oil corrects? None of the above: It
is still possible that none of the above potential disasters may happen anytime
soon. The Fed may be successful in steering the US economy away from a recession,
using further rate cuts, even if growth decelerates further. Oil prices may settle
around current levels, but lower interest rates may support consumer spending
from slipping. US housing sector may bottom out and even help absorb any
potential slack in other segments. Corporate margins may not fall further as global
growth refuses to slow down. Emerging economies may continue to lead the global
expansion. Most of the ghosts in the credit markets may have already been exorcised
and liquidity may continue to flood global markets. This perfect scenario,
which appears rather improbable now, could lead to a sustained up-trend in equity
prices. It could also lead to even more investor complacency and exuberance, which
usually end in absolute disasters. Some of the above: A more probable
scenario is that some of the above mentioned troubles will hit the market in the
short to medium term. That would mean more wild rides for the stock indices, as
bouts of frenzied buying will be interspersed by panic selling. So, what
do we do? At the end of the day, if you are a trader, you cannot argue with markets.
You have to move with the tide, whether markets are exuberant, panicky or just
indifferent. Investors with reasonably long horizons have the luxury of arguing
with markets - and surviving to tell the story - entering when markets are panicky
and exiting when things get frothy. It
may be a good idea to ''cash some of the chips'', if you have not already done so.
If your favourite holding period is ''forever'' or something close to that, none
of these matter. Unless, of course, you are a latecomer to the party!
|