PlanetSpace protest may hit NASA programme
27 Jan 2009
In spite of the recession, NASA signed deals totalling $3.5 billion under its Commercial Resupply Services (CRS) programme just before Christmas, naming PayPal and electric-car hecamillionaire Elon Musk Musk's SpaceX venture and Virginia-based Orbital Science Corporation as providers of space lift to the International Space Station. Last week, however, rival firm PlanetSpace said it had filed a formal protest with the US government accountability office (GAO).
The protest effectively prevents the NASA CRS, meant to resupply its space station, from moving forward until the GAO rules on whether the procurement process was properly carried out, which has to do within 90 days.
Even If the process is upheld, further lengthy delays could be expected before any new decision by NASA. A decision last year by the GAO that the US air force had acted improperly in awarding a multibillion-dollar aerial tanker contract to Europe's Airbus rather than America's Boeing has left the air force's tanker buying push effectively paralysed.
The tanker decision was seen by many as politically driven, with strong rhetoric about American jobs and tech superiority heard on Capitol Hill before the ruling (though Airbus had planned to place much of the work in the US.) PlanetSpace looks to be trying the same tactics as Boeing, saying that their CRS bid is "all-US - something that ought to be a domestic priority in the light of current economic conditions".
The PlanetSpace alliance includes traditional heavyweight US rocketry suppliers Lockheed, ATK and Boeing, a trio that wields enormous clout in Washington, and they can exert more political pressure than relative minnows like SpaceX and Orbital.
While PlanetSpace planned to use the Athena III rocket, derived from long-established earlier models, SpaceX plans to carry out the CRS flights using its brand-new Falcon 9 rocket and Dragon capsule, which have never flown. Musk's venture has, however, achieved a successful flight to orbit on the fourth attempt using the equally new, smaller Falcon 1.
Orbital also plans to field new technology in the form of its Taurus II medium-lift rocket. To date, the firm's main experience has been in lifting very small satellites to orbit using the Pegasus rocket, which is launched from a modified TriStar airliner at 40,000 feet.
With NASA keen to retire the Space Shuttle on schedule next year, the space agency will be frustrated at this delay to the CRS effort and hopeful that the GAO won't uphold the PlanetSpace protest. Should the protest be upheld, it will be back to square one for NASA - and America will be even more dependent in future on Russian Soyuz and European "Jules Verne" spacecraft to supply the space station, American taxpayers have shelled out colossal sums to build and operate.
