Finding a good story for Google in China will be difficult

23 Oct 2010

Finding a good story for Google in China is going to be tough, says Andreas Pouros, chief operating officer at Greenlight, a leading independent search specialist marketing and technology firm. His comments follow on the back of Baidu's results.

These show it continues to dominate the search engine landscape in China. Baidu also reported its advertiser numbers have increased by almost 26 per cent on 2009 levels, reaching 272,000 - a clear sign of the deep chasm in the paid search arena between it and its nearest rival, Google.
 
Since June, Google has curtailed its searchable Web index to comply with China's censorship laws. According to Pouros, as it now provides fewer results, it cannot post as many advertisements as it had previously. Furthermore, research earlier this year from leading media-focused research, publishing and consulting company, Screen Digest, indicates almost two thirds of search users are happy to use Baidu or smaller Chinese search engines.
 
According to Cyrine Amor, advertising analyst at Screen Digest, Google is losing market share with the problems it encountered lately with the government. Moreover, Google is also about to end its contracts with seven adwords resellers in China. No reason has been provided for this but Ms Amor says this will likely see Google's share slashed by up to 10-12 per cent.
 
Screen Digest's figures from earlier this year show Google accounted for 33 per cent share of the Chinese search market, behind Baidu.
 
In paid search, Baidu has been enjoying a healthy lead. In early 2010, Screen Digest estimated total online advertising revenues in China would reach almost 1.5 billion in 2010, with Baidu accounting for the lion's share ($945 million), then Google with $472 million.
 
By having over 60 per cent share of the search market in China, has Baidu reached the tipping point much as Google had in western Europe, where its growth from 60 per cent-90 per cent share was incredibly rapid, with its competitors largely incapable of closing the gap? Perhaps it has, says Pouros. What is certain, according to Pouros, is that Google needs a new game plan if it is to achieve the momentum required to catch a clear home grown market leader.

Table 1: China - Search Engine Share of Paid Search Revenues
2008
2009
2010
Baidu
$m
468
651
945
Google
$m
207
326
472
Others
$m
63
40
59
Total
$m
738
1,017
1,475
yoy change
$m
38%
45%
Source: Company reports, i-research, Screen Digest estimates
Note: constant exchange rate (average 2009: 1 USD=6.83 RMB)